The Great Fire had claimed many things from London: entire parishes, ancient churches, and ten thousand homes. Still, it failed to purge the city’s capacity for human misery. In the charred skeleton of what had once been Newgate gaol, masons worked through the bitter December cold, their breath forming clouds as they raised new walls upon foundations that had witnessed centuries of suffering. Like the mythical phoenix, the prison would rise again from its ashes. However, what emerged would be no creature of beauty or redemption.
The flames of September 1666 had gutted the ancient gaol, melting the iron bars and reducing timber to ash, yet within months, the essential machinery of confinement had resumed its grim operations. While the complete reconstruction would not finish until 1672, makeshift quarters already housed the overflow of London’s unwanted debtors, felons, religious dissidents, and those whose only crime was poverty in a city that demanded coin for mercy.
Sir Richard Ford, the Recorder, would later confide to Samuel Pepys that Newgate had become “the only nursery of rogues, prostitutes, pickpockets, and thieves in the world, where they were bred and entertained, and the whole society met.” Walter Cowday’s keeper wielded such influence that even the sheriffs “durst not commit him, for fear of making him let out the prisoners, but are fain to go by artifice to deal with him.”
The rebuilding efforts incorporated remnants of the Commonwealth expansion. Buildings that had once housed the Phoenix Inn on Newgate Street were absorbed into the prison’s growing maw. A place of hospitality transformed into an instrument of despair, its former warmth replaced by the cold arithmetic of extortion and neglect.
Within these rising walls, a universe of stratified suffering took shape. The prison’s “sides” reflected not justice but the brutal economics of desperation. The Master Debtors’ Side and Press Yard offered relative luxury for those who could afford exorbitant fees. Chambers had actual beds, albeit “bedsteads made of boards” with “neither flocks nor feathers. ” Walls were sometimes ‘bedaubed with texts of Scripture written in charcoal’ by prisoners seeking divine intervention in their earthly hell.
But the Common Side truly embodied Newgate’s essence, a place Colonel John Turner, awaiting execution in 1662, had described as “the most fearful, sad, deplorable place. Hell itself, in comparison, cannot be such a place. There is neither bench, stool, nor stick for any person there; they lie like swine upon the ground, one upon another, howling and roaring; it was more terrible to me than this death.”
The Lodge served as the portal to this netherworld, where new arrivals faced their first taste of Newgate’s unique hospitality. Fresh prisoners were immediately “mulcted on first arrival at the lodge for drink and ‘garnish'”—a system of tribute that began with four shillings to the turnkeys but quickly escalated as other inmates demanded their share. One unfortunate soul recorded how he “had no sooner paid the Four Shillings Garnish to the Turnkeys, in their Lodge… but I was immediately surrounded by the Gentlemen of the Press Yard, demanding their Garnish too… I found I had run out a Guinea and a Half” merely for the privilege of entry.
Adjacent to the Lodge lay the Condemned Hold, a chamber of particular dread where those awaiting execution, those deliberately placed there to encourage payment for better quarters, experienced what one prisoner called a “panic dread.” From above, voices would call down with offers of salvation for “a valuable consideration”: “Sir, I understand that you are a Gentleman too well Educated to take up your abode in a vault set aside only for Thieves, Parricides and Murderers… you may be removed to a Chamber equal to one in any private House where you may be furnished with the best Conversation.”
The fees for such “better” accommodation could reach twenty guineas entrance plus eleven weekly shillings, bankrupting a gentleman and ensuring a commoner’s permanent residence among the condemned. These prices were not accidents but careful calculations designed to extract every possible coin from prisoners and their families before abandoning them to the Common Side’s horrors.
Disease moved through Newgate like a plague ship’s cargo. The “malignant disease, the gaol fever, was chronic, and deaths from it of frequent occurrence.” Even by 1697, reports would speak of “infectious fever in Newgate, of which several were sick and some dead.” The fetid air, thick with the exhalations of unwashed bodies and inadequate sanitation, created conditions one contemporary described as “an abominable sink of beastliness and corruption.”
Yet, within this kingdom of suffering, a perverse society flourished. The Press Yard resembled “the taproom of a common inn,” where gambling and unlimited drinking provided profit for keepers and temporary oblivion for prisoners. “Deep potations” were common, with keepers and turnkeys joining the revelry when bribed. The “morning forfeit”, a groat in drink for the turnkeys from those who had overindulged, was collected “very punctually,” adding another layer to the complex economy of vice that sustained the prison’s operations.
Discipline, when it existed at all, served profit rather than order. Prisoners could freely interact with visitors, including those with a “predilection for criminal society.” This laxity was intentional; Newgate functioned as a prison and criminal university, where offences were planned and false currency fabricated. The mixing of debtors and felons, the unlimited access to alcohol, and the systematic corruption of staff all contributed to an environment that manufactured the very crimes it was meant to punish.
The prison’s role in London’s judicial theatre extended beyond mere confinement. Condemned prisoners were drawn in carts from Newgate to Tyburn, their final journey a public spectacle that reinforced social order through the display of state power. The Ordinary of Newgate, a clergyman whose duties included visiting the condemned, compiled accounts of their behaviour and dying speeches for publication—a profitable venture that required cooperation from prisoners who might otherwise prefer silence.
As 1667 drew to a close, Newgate stood as a testament to London’s capacity for regeneration and stagnation. The fire had destroyed the old structure, but could not burn away the institutional cruelty that defined it. New walls rose upon ancient foundations of suffering, staffed by the same rapacious keepers, governed by the same ruthless economics of desperation.
The city around it bustled with reconstruction, Christopher Wren’s churches reaching toward heaven, merchants rebuilding their fortunes, and the great work of renewal that would transform London into a modern metropolis. However, within Newgate’s walls, time moved differently. In the shadows of London’s rebirth, the old darkness persisted, feeding on human weakness and systemic corruption with an appetite that no fire could diminish.
It was in this world, part prison, part marketplace, part theatre of cruelty, that London’s unwanted disappeared, their fates determined not by justice but by their ability to pay for mercy in a system that had commodified human dignity. The phoenix had risen, but it wore the face of a vulture, and its song was the eternal lament of the abandoned and the damned.
In this half-burnt, destroyed pit of despair, the cell walls oozed damp, closing in around Thomas Penrose as he sank into the depths of despair. Moisture trickled down the rough-hewn stone in sinuous rivulets, pooling darkly on the filthy floor. Once, in another life, he had stood proud on scrubbed oak decks, leading men into battle. The air hung thick and stale, fouled by the rising human desperation. Smoke from the drinking cellars below, where gaolers and privileged inmates sought oblivion in cups of sack and ale, the reek of bodies pressed too closely in corridors never meant to house so many souls. The unmistakable sour stench of fever and mortality.
He sat motionless, freezing, on the splintered bench, back rigid against the cold stone as though still at attention on the quarterdeck. Thomas Penrose, once the commander of five of His Majesty’s vessels of war, a veteran of three great naval battles against the Dutch, and captor of prizes worth a king’s ransom, was now reduced to measuring time by the mournful tolling of distant bells that penetrated the thick stone of Newgate. Their sound reached him as if through water, distorted and hollow, marking hours that no longer held purpose or promise.
The prison bore the scars of London’s recent cataclysm just as Penrose bore the marks of his fall from grace. Blackened timbers had been replaced with unseasoned wood that warped and creaked in protest. Stone walls, cracked by intense heat, had been patched carelessly with whatever materials came to hand. Through gaps in mortar and ill-fitted bricks, the bitter wind whistled a ceaseless dirge, carrying the sting of hail that occasionally spattered through the barred, glassless window set high in the wall, a mocking reminder of freedom beyond reach.
The chains around his ankles clinked gently as he shifted position, a discordant counterpoint to the steady water drip from the leaking roof. Iron manacles, cold and unforgiving, had been his constant companions until he had paid to have them removed from his wrists. The flesh remained raw and inflamed, a physical manifestation of dignity surrendered for momentary comfort. Everything in Newgate carried its price, released from bonds, clean straw, and food that might sustain rather than sicken. The gaolers had learned long ago to extract coin from misery with the same precision with which Penrose had once extracted maximum speed from a well-trimmed sail.
His meagre purse had emptied quickly. Only pride remained, that most worthless of currencies in a place where men were stripped of all pretence.
The memory came unbidden in the cellblock’s twilight, not as an organised narrative but as sensory fragments that cut more deeply than any blade. The salt spray of the Channel whipped across his face as the Monck plunged through heavy seas. The precise weight of a sextant in his palm. The particular quality of morning light reflecting off distant sails that might be friend or foe. The thunderous symphony of thirty-four guns firing in disciplined sequence. The metallic taste of fear transmuted into resolve as Dutch broadsides splintered English oak around him.
He had known terror then; what sane man would not? But never had it mastered him. In the crucible of battle, when lesser men cowered or fled, Thomas Penrose had found himself. He had stood unflinching as iron shots screamed overhead, given orders in a voice that carried above the cacophony of war, and inspired men to acts of valour they would later struggle to comprehend in quieter moments.
“Steady, lads,” he had called on the blood-slicked deck of the Nonsuch during the Battle of Portland, even as the mainmast shuddered ominously above them. “England sees your courage this day!”
England. The word itself was a wound now, salt-rubbed and festering.
He had given everything to England, his youth, strength, faith, and fortune. He had commanded her ships through storm and battle, taken prizes in her name, bled upon her decks, and watched good men die beneath her colours. He transferred unwavering loyalty to Charles II upon the Restoration, always believing in the continuity of national purpose beyond the vagaries of politics.
And for what? To end here, in this liminal space between judgment and execution, forgotten by the nation he had defended? To have his life’s service reduced to notations in Admiralty ledgers, his reputation tarnished by one moment of ungovernable rage, his legacy nothing but cautionary whispers in taverns frequented by naval officers?
He who had commanded vast horizons was now confined to six paces in any direction. He, navigated by starlight, now saw the sky only in fragmentary glimpses through iron bars. He who had directed the movements of hundreds now watched helplessly as rats scurried with greater freedom than he possessed.
Penrose closed his eyes, surrendering momentarily to the fever that had begun to burn behind them with increasing insistence. The cough that racked him tasted of iron, blood, perhaps, or simply the memory of gunmetal and cannon and something else, something earthier and more final. He recognised the harbingers of approaching death with the same dispassionate assessment he had once applied to weather patterns or enemy fleet formations.
Not long now, he thought. Days, perhaps. A week at most.
Around him, Newgate breathed its fetid breath, hundreds of souls compressed into spaces never designed for such numbers. The Great Fire had destroyed the old prison. Still, even in rebuilding, no allowance had been made for dignity or basic human needs. Bodies pressed against bodies in corridors, and men slept in shifts because there was no room to lie down simultaneously. The disease moved among them like a silent predator, claiming the weakest first but eventually affecting all.
Yet even in this purgatory, hierarchy persisted. As a gentleman and a naval captain, however disgraced, Penrose was granted the dubious privilege of solitude. With its rough bench and mouldering straw, this damp cell was considered preferential treatment, reflecting his former status. He had heard rumours of the common holding areas below. In these nightmare spaces, felons and debtors, drunkards and political prisoners were packed so tightly they could scarcely move, where fights erupted over crusts of bread, where the dying were stripped of clothing before they had drawn their final breath.
He had not been formally condemned. No judge had pronounced a sentence, and no date had been set for his journey to Tyburn. Yet in Newgate, such technicalities meant little. Men died awaiting trial just as readily as those already sentenced, claimed by disease or despair long before they could mount a defence.
What would he say in his defence if given the opportunity? That Lampeer had provoked him beyond endurance? Did the man’s sneering dismissal of naval sacrifice ignite something primal and ungovernable? That the push had been meant to silence, not to kill?
All true, perhaps. Not sufficient.
The confrontation at the stairhead played again in his mind’s eye, Lampeer’s flushed face, the man’s voice slurred with wine yet cutting in its contempt for “failed captains” and “Commonwealth relics.” The surge of rage that had blinded Penrose momentarily, the sensation of his hands against fine broadcloth, the look of surprise rather than fear on Lampeer’s face as he lost his balance, the sickening sequence of impacts as the body tumbled down the steep stairs, the awful stillness that followed.
“You cannot flee who you are,” his father had told him once on the Cornish cliffs of his youth. “The sea will claim you as it claimed me and your grandfather. Penrose men answer the call of tide and horizon.”
His father had meant it as prophecy, as a blessing. It had proven to be judgment instead.
It was not the sea that had claimed Thomas Penrose in the end, not the honest danger of storm or enemy fire. It was a treacherous, shifting, political land that had undone him. The land with its taverns, where naval officers gathered to reminisce about past campaigns. The land with its corridors of power, where men who had never smelled salt air determined the fate of those who lived by tide and wind. The land with its fickle memory that forgot service but remembered scandal.
A spasm of coughing bent him double, pain lancing through his chest. When it subsided, he tasted blood, no more extended memory but immediate reality. The fever was advancing more rapidly than he had calculated. Perhaps it would claim him before the hangman could, a final act of agency in a life increasingly defined by powers beyond his control.
Rising with effort, chains rattling a grim accompaniment to his movements, Penrose crossed to the narrow window and strained to see beyond the bars. The November sky hung low and leaden over London, its smokestacks and spires barely visible through slanting hail and fog. Somewhere out there, life continued. Ships docked and departed, merchants traded, nobles schemed, and the vast machinery of empire ground forward without pause or reflection.
What would he say to her if he were granted one final meeting? What wisdom could a fallen man possibly impart?
Perhaps only this: that England demanded loyalty but offered none in return. That service was its reward because no other might be forthcoming. Those principles, once yielded, were impossible to reclaim.
Penrose returned to his bench, lowering himself heavily as exhaustion swept through him like an advancing tide. The walls continued their silent weeping, water tracking the same patient paths down the stone it had followed for centuries before him and would follow for centuries after. Time in Newgate existed outside normal measure, simultaneously crawling and rushing, each moment eternal yet racing toward an inevitable conclusion.
He closed his eyes, not in surrender but in temporary retreat. Let the fever take him where it would. Let memory carry him back to the salt wind and open horizons. Let darkness offer what light had long since withdrawn: the possibility, however illusory, of justice.
For all he had given, blood, youth, faith, and future, he was left with shadows, silence, and the bitter knowledge that loyalty, once the cornerstone of his existence, was ultimately a one-way tide, flowing eternally outward with never a returning surge.
Discover more from Random Ramblings by Robert Steers
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.